Comparing: Valentine AT vs. FCM 36 Pak 40 vs. Renault UE 57

GB42_Valentine_AT

This experimental tank destroyer had the gun mounted in the middle of the hull behind a gun shield. A prototype was built, but work on the vehicle was discontinued when a new tank destroyer was developed, based on the Valentine and mounting the powerful 17-pounder.

FCM_36Pak40

In 1943, ten FCM36 tanks were converted into tank destroyers. Earlier, 12 vehicles of this type were converted into self-propelled guns carrying a 105-mm gun.

RenaultUE57

Developed in 1943 in Great Britain by mounting the British 6-pounder gun on the chassis of the French tankette UE2. One prototype was manufactured.

Modules
Auto select
Turrets
Guns
Engines
Suspensions
Radios
Main Characteristics
Tank data page Tank data page Tank data page Tank data page
Tier III III III
Battle Tiers 3 4 5 3 4 5 3 4 5
Price 34,000 850 42,500
Hit Points
Signal range
Speed Limit24 km/h24 km/h36 km/h
Speed Limit Back12 km/h10 km/h12 km/h
Weight
Load limit
Crew
  • Commander (Gunner, Radio Operator)
  • Driver
  • Loader
  • Commander (Radio Operator)
  • Gunner
  • Driver
  • Loader
  • Commander (Radio Operator)
  • Gunner
  • Driver
  • Loader
Armor
Hull Armor
Front:
60 mm
Side:
60 mm
Rear:
60 mm
Front:
40 mm
Side:
20 mm
Rear:
40 mm
Front:
9 mm
Side:
6 mm
Rear:
6 mm
Turret Armor
Mobility
Engine Power
Horse power / weight
Traverse Speed
Max Climb Angle
Hard terrain resistance
Medium terrain resistance
Soft terrain resistance
Fire Chance
Engine Type
Turret
View Range
Turret Traverse
Traverse Arc
Armament
Damage (Explosion radius)
Penetration
Shell Price
Shell Speed
Damage / min
Rate of Fire
Reload time
Clip
Accuracy
Aim time
Elevation Arc
Ammo Capacity
Camo value
Stationary %21.50 %26.75 %
In motion %15.50 %26.75 %
When Firing %7.57 %10.18 %
Battle performance
Accuracy43.497 %58.5475 %47.8418 %
Neto Credits Income2482.734946.711988.61
Winrate49.191 %55.334 %49.0959 %
Damage dealt157.335337.314139.987
Kills per Battle0.5456751.108260.450319
More stats @ vbaddict.net More stats More stats More stats