Comparing: Excelsior vs. Churchill I

GB51_Excelsior

At the end of 1942, the Churchill tank's armament was deemed insufficient. New tanks, the A31, A32, and A33 were developed as new infantry tanks. The A33 was developed by the English Electric Company. The LMS Company participated in the development of suspension for a new tank. Two vehicles, which differed greatly from each other, were manufactured. The A33 was set to go into production, but in 1943 the decision to cancel mass production of the Churchill was reversed, and the order for the A33 was not placed.

GB08_Churchill_I

The A22 prototype was built by Vauxhall Motors in the fall of 1940. The vehicle first entered mass production in the summer of 1941. Early modifications had no track fenders, a different fan, and a 3-inch howitzer in the hull. A total of 300 Churchill I tanks were manufactured.

Modules
Auto select
Turrets
Guns
Engines
Suspensions
Radios
Main Characteristics
Tank data page Tank data page Tank data page
Tier V V
Battle Tiers 5 6 5 6 7
Price 1,500 340,000
Hit Points 670 HP 650 HP
Signal range 570 m 400 m
Speed Limit38.6 km/h25.7 km/h
Speed Limit Back12 km/h14 km/h
Weight 41.048 t 38.447 t
Load limit 44.10 t 39.00 t
Crew
  • Commander
  • Gunner
  • Driver
  • Radio Operator
  • Loader
  • Commander (Radio Operator)
  • Driver
  • Gunner
  • Gunner
  • Loader
Armor
Hull Armor
Front:
114.3 mm
Side:
31.75 mm
Rear:
108 mm
Front:
177.8 mm
Side:
63.5 mm
Rear:
50.8 mm
Turret Armor
Front:
114.3 mm
Side:
92.1 mm
Rear:
92.1 mm
Front:
101.6 mm
Side:
88.9 mm
Rear:
88.9 mm
Mobility
Engine Power 600 hp 300 hp
Horse power / weight 14.62 hp/t 7.80 hp/t
Traverse Speed 32 d/s 20 d/s
Max Climb Angle 25 25
Hard terrain resistance 1.40 1.10
Medium terrain resistance 1.50 1.40
Soft terrain resistance 2.90 2.30
Fire Chance 20 % 20 %
Engine Type Gasoline Gasoline
Turret
View Range 350 m 330 m
Turret Traverse 36 d/s 34 d/s
Traverse Arc 360 360
Armament
Damage (Explosion radius)
AP
110 HP
APCR
110 HP
HE
175 HP (1.06 m)
AP
50 HP
APCR
50 HP
HE
60 HP (0.35 m)
Penetration
AP
91 mm
APCR
144 mm
HE
38 mm
AP
78 mm
APCR
121 mm
HE
23 mm
Shell Price
AP
56
APCR
7 (gold)
HE
56
AP
30
APCR
3 (gold)
HE
15
Shell Speed
AP
619 m/s
APCR
774 m/s
HE
619 m/s
AP
792 m/s
APCR
990 m/s
HE
792 m/s
Damage / min
AP
1736.9 HP/min
APCR
1736.9 HP/min
HE
2763.25 HP/min
AP
1428.5 HP/min
APCR
1428.5 HP/min
HE
1714.2 HP/min
Rate of Fire 15.79 r/m 28.57 r/m
Reload time 3.80 s 2.10 s
Clip / /
Accuracy 0.42 m 0.36 m
Aim time 2.30 s 1.70 s
Elevation Arc
Ammo Capacity 64 rounds 150 rounds
Camo value
Stationary %14.00 %
In motion %9.00 %
When Firing %3.18 %
Battle performance
Accuracy61.2809 %57.3421 %
Neto Credits Income-2318.635032.13
Winrate49.5646 %47.6952 %
Damage dealt368.948316.265
Kills per Battle0.8067860.536413
More stats @ vbaddict.net More stats More stats