Comparing: Covenanter vs. Valentine vs. M5A1 Stuart

GB60_Covenanter

A new cruiser tank that featured such innovations as an opposed-piston engine, front placement of cooling radiators, and the wide use of welding. The vehicle was ordered for production on April 17, 1939. A total of 1,771 tanks in four base variants were mass-produced. The Covenanter tanks were used mostly for training purposes in the U.K. from 1940 through 1943.

GB04_Valentine

Developed in 1938 by Vickers-Armstrong, the tank was one of the best in its class. A total of 8275 vehicles in various modifications were manufactured from 1940 through 1944.

Ch09_M5

The first tanks of the M5 series were produced in April 1942, and a new modification, the M5A1, was preferred over other variants. After the M24 Chaffee was developed, the M5A1 tanks were deemed obsolete and were exported to other countries, including China. A total of 100 tanks of this type were supplied to the Kuomintang. During the Civil War (1946–1949), many of these vehicles were captured by the PLA.

Modules
Auto select
Turrets
Guns
Engines
Suspensions
Radios
Main Characteristics
Tank data page Tank data page Tank data page Tank data page
Tier IV IV IV
Battle Tiers 4 5 6 4 5 6 4 5 6 7
Price 110,000 120,000 143,000
Hit Points 310 HP 310 HP 310 HP
Signal range 375 m 350 m 395 m
Speed Limit50 km/h24 km/h64.4 km/h
Speed Limit Back20 km/h10 km/h20 km/h
Weight 18.154 t 16.257 t 15.56 t
Load limit 18.20 t 16.50 t 15.75 t
Crew
  • Commander (Radio Operator)
  • Gunner
  • Driver
  • Loader
  • Commander (Gunner, Radio Operator)
  • Driver
  • Loader
  • Commander (Loader)
  • Gunner (Loader)
  • Driver
  • Radio Operator
Armor
Hull Armor
Front:
40 mm
Side:
30 mm
Rear:
25 mm
Front:
60 mm
Side:
60 mm
Rear:
60 mm
Front:
28.6 mm
Side:
28.6 mm
Rear:
25.4 mm
Turret Armor
Front:
39 mm
Side:
19.5 mm
Rear:
25 mm
Front:
65 mm
Side:
60 mm
Rear:
65 mm
Front:
38.1 mm
Side:
31.8 mm
Rear:
31.8 mm
Mobility
Engine Power 300 hp 135 hp 296 hp
Horse power / weight 16.53 hp/t 8.30 hp/t 19.02 hp/t
Traverse Speed 38 d/s 40 d/s 36 d/s
Max Climb Angle 25 25 25
Hard terrain resistance 1.00 1.00 0.90
Medium terrain resistance 1.20 1.30 1.00
Soft terrain resistance 2.00 2.00 2.00
Fire Chance 20 % 20 % 20 %
Engine Type Gasoline Gasoline Gasoline
Turret
View Range 330 m 330 m 330 m
Turret Traverse 48 d/s 44 d/s 48 d/s
Traverse Arc 360 360 360
Armament
Damage (Explosion radius)
AP
50 HP
APCR
50 HP
HE
60 HP (0.35 m)
AP
50 HP
APCR
50 HP
HE
60 HP (0.35 m)
AP
40 HP
APCR
40 HP
HE
50 HP (0.31 m)
Penetration
AP
78 mm
APCR
121 mm
HE
23 mm
AP
78 mm
APCR
121 mm
HE
23 mm
AP
56 mm
APCR
78 mm
HE
19 mm
Shell Price
AP
30
APCR
3 (gold)
HE
15
AP
30
APCR
3 (gold)
HE
15
AP
18
APCR
2 (gold)
HE
10
Shell Speed
AP
792 m/s
APCR
990 m/s
HE
792 m/s
AP
792 m/s
APCR
990 m/s
HE
792 m/s
AP
792 m/s
APCR
990 m/s
HE
792 m/s
Damage / min
AP
1428.5 HP/min
APCR
1428.5 HP/min
HE
1714.2 HP/min
AP
1428.5 HP/min
APCR
1428.5 HP/min
HE
1714.2 HP/min
AP
1043.6 HP/min
APCR
1043.6 HP/min
HE
1304.5 HP/min
Rate of Fire 28.57 r/m 28.57 r/m 26.09 r/m
Reload time 2.10 s 2.10 s 2.30 s
Clip / / /
Accuracy 0.36 m 0.36 m 0.42 m
Aim time 1.70 s 1.70 s 1.70 s
Elevation Arc
Ammo Capacity 130 rounds 60 rounds 123 rounds
Camo value
Stationary19.00 %20.00 %18.85 %
In motion19.00 %17.00 %18.85 %
When Firing4.91 %4.97 %5.20 %
Battle performance
Accuracy45.4835 %52.3257 %49.6406 %
Neto Credits Income1742.343198.452604.52
Winrate48.0151 %48.1009 %48.5004 %
Damage dealt127.339161.53895.0769
Kills per Battle0.3240720.3625770.17668
More stats @ vbaddict.net More stats More stats More stats